Independent Analytics – WordPress Analytics Plugin vs WP Statistics – Simple, privacy-friendly Google Analytics alternative (2026): PluginCheck
Quick Verdict
Pick WP Statistics if you want a battle-tested plugin with deep traffic analysis features and a proven track record on hundreds of thousands of sites. Pick Independent Analytics if you prefer a cleaner, more focused experience with outstanding user satisfaction ratings.
Both Independent Analytics and WP Statistics offer privacy-friendly, self-hosted alternatives to Google Analytics for WordPress site owners who want to keep visitor data on their own servers. The choice comes down to whether you prioritise a refined, polished user experience or a feature-rich dashboard with a larger install base. Both plugins are actively maintained and compatible with current WordPress versions.
Independent Analytics – WordPress Analytics Plugin
A simple, yet powerful WordPress analytics plugin that gives you privacy-friendly stats to grow your website. A Google Analytics alternative.
- Active installs 100k+
- Rating 4.8/5 (161)
- Last updated May 19, 2026
- Support resolved 100%
- Tested to WP 7.0
- Requires PHP 7.4
WP Statistics – Simple, privacy-friendly Google Analytics alternative
Get website traffic insights with GDPR/CCPA compliant, privacy-friendly analytics. Includes visitor data, stunning graphs, and no data sharing.
- Active installs 600k+
- Rating 4.1/5 (756)
- Last updated May 19, 2026
- Support resolved 87%
- Tested to WP 7.0
- Requires PHP 7.4
Where Independent Analytics – WordPress Analytics Plugin Wins
User satisfaction
Independent Analytics scores 96/100 from 161 ratings, a notably higher rating than WP Statistics' 82/100 from 756 ratings, indicating a more polished user experience.
Support resolution
Independent Analytics resolves 100% of support tickets compared to WP Statistics' 86.7%, meaning users are far more likely to get a working answer when they need help.
Where WP Statistics – Simple, privacy-friendly Google Analytics alternative Wins
Install base and popularity
WP Statistics has 600,000 active installs, six times more than Independent Analytics' 100,000, reflecting broader adoption and trust across the WordPress community.
Number of reviews
WP Statistics has 756 ratings, giving you a much larger sample of community feedback to evaluate before installing compared to Independent Analytics' 161 ratings.
Score-by-Score Comparison
WP Statistics wins on popularity (86 vs 75) thanks to its 600,000 active installs compared to Independent Analytics' 100,000.
Both plugins are tied on maintenance, each scoring a perfect 100, with recent updates in May 2026 confirming active development.
Independent Analytics has the edge on ratings (96 vs 82), suggesting a higher proportion of happy users despite the smaller review pool.
Independent Analytics leads on support (100 vs 87), with perfect ticket resolution versus WP Statistics' strong but imperfect 86.7%.
Both plugins are tied on compatibility, each scoring a perfect 100 in PluginCheck's testing.
The Bottom Line
WP Statistics is the safer default pick for most users. Its 600,000 installs and broader feature set make it the stronger general-purpose choice, even though the Quality Score is nearly identical (91.79 vs 91.18). Independent Analytics is the better option if you value a polished experience, top-rated user satisfaction, and reliable support, and you do not need the deeper analytics tooling WP Statistics provides. For a new site owner who just wants privacy-friendly stats that work, WP Statistics' maturity and scale edge it out.